Homes for Sale in Tenafly, NJ
Tenafly is a leafy, family-oriented Bergen County borough along the Palisades — known for strong public schools, an active downtown, and a mix of mid-century and luxury single-family homes.
Active Listings in Tenafly
12 homes for sale right now
$1,650,000
Est. $11,891/mo
37 Oak Street
Listed by Elevate Realty
$3,490,000
Est. $25,151/mo
44 Floral Terrace
Listed by Elevate Realty
$950,000
Est. $6,846/mo
12 Louise Lane
Listed by Elevate Realty
$3,600,000
Est. $25,944/mo
89 Depeyster Avenue
Listed by Elevate Realty
$1,850,000
Est. $13,332/mo
12 Cameron Road
Listed by Elevate Realty
$1,650,000
Est. $11,891/mo
229 Hickory Avenue
Listed by Elevate Realty
$2,150,000
Est. $15,494/mo
44 George Street
Listed by Elevate Realty
$2,499,000
Est. $18,009/mo
90 Columbus Drive
Listed by Elevate Realty
$2,999,000
Est. $21,612/mo
23 Benjamin Road
Listed by Elevate Realty
$3,288,000
Est. $23,695/mo
14 Old Smith Road
Listed by Elevate Realty
$6,500,000
Est. $46,843/mo
55 Oxford Drive
Listed by Elevate Realty
$3,395,000
Est. $24,466/mo
8 Stanton Road
Listed by Elevate Realty
About the Tenafly Real Estate Market
Tenafly's real estate market is anchored by single-family homes on generous lots — most properties trade between $900K and $2.5M, with premium estates in the Smith School and East Hill sections exceeding $3M. The town's downtown along Washington Street and County Road has been steadily revitalized with new restaurants, retail, and the modernized Tenafly Community Center. Tenafly Public Schools is one of the strongest K-12 districts in Bergen County, drawing many families from NYC and other NJ towns. Commuters use NJ Transit buses to the Port Authority (~45 min) or drive to Englewood/Fort Lee for express options. Inventory turns over slowly — Tenafly homes are typically held for 10-20+ years. Properties near Tenafly Nature Center and on the East Hill (closer to the Palisades) command premiums for their views and lot sizes.
Notable Neighborhoods in Tenafly
- Smith School district
- East Hill
- Downtown / Washington Street
- Maugham School area
Schools
Tenafly Public Schools — particularly Smith and Maugham Elementary plus Tenafly High — is one of Bergen County's strongest districts.
Commute to NYC
NJ Transit buses to Port Authority; ~45-55 minutes to midtown.
Frequently Asked Questions About Tenafly Real Estate
What's the median home price in Tenafly, NJ?
Median home prices in Tenafly typically range from $1M-$1.6M for single-family homes. East Hill and Smith School area properties command premiums above this range.
How are Tenafly schools rated?
Tenafly Public Schools is consistently ranked in the top 5% of NJ public school districts, particularly for STEM and AP coursework.
Is Tenafly a good place for families?
Yes — Tenafly is widely considered one of the most family-friendly Bergen County towns due to its schools, parks, low crime rates, and active community programs.